Are Invisible Dog Fences Humane?

Invisible underground or wireless fences can easily be installed. These are the most preferred methods for confining a dog to a yard without putting up a wall. But are these systems that use a buried wire transmitting a radio signal humane for dogs?

How Invisible Dog Fences Work

An invisible dog fence system involves a thin wire buried slightly below the ground within a compound, particularly the compound’s perimeter. A radio signal passes through the wire. The dog wears a receiver collar that monitors the signal given. The collar gives out a warning beep as the dog nears the demarcated line. If the dog goes further and crosses the line, the collar gives him a harmless electric shock. In other words, the shock associated with the boundary is effectively taught through consistent repetition and training.

The Upsides to Invisible Dog Fences

Freedom of Movement

In contrast to any conventional fence or a tie-out, an invisible wall enables the dog to run freely within the compound while avoiding the chance of escaping and roaming freely. This affords them the opportunity to play and roam more.

Cost

The cost of installing an underground fence is considerably less expensive compared to the amount one would spend when fencing the same area using the conventional above-the-ground fencing technique. It offers a more affordable method of providing dogs some space while at the same time ensuring their safety.

Customizable Boundaries

The boundary wire can be placed according to the shape of  the yard as well as where the owner wants the dog to have freedom. It is less complicated to shift than a fence that is rigid and unmovable.

Minimal Impact on Landscape

Unlike a chain link or wood privacy fence, invisible dog fences do not hinder views or block sunlight. The only noticeable features are tiny boundary cones and the collar worn by the dog. This makes them perfect for people who wish to contain their dogs but without having to change the natural appearance of the land.

The Disadvantages of Invisible Dog Fences

Pain and Stress

The shock intensity is not very high, but dogs have to get a shock every time they try to cross the invisible line, which is uncomfortable. A few dogs can develop severe anxiety or even become afraid to run around the yard due to attempts to escape the shocks.

The fence is quite helpful in keeping pets contained inside the yard, but it in no way prevents other animals from accessing the yard. Dogs are still capable of being incited by people passing the compound, being harassed by children, or being attacked by other animals that may intrude onto the property. Your dog may feel confined in the yard because they understand that touching any part of it may give them an electric shock.

Training Difficulties

It is essential to train your dogs sufficiently to avoid getting too close to the fence, where they may receive a frequent shock. However, there are some problems in generalizing the concept of the boundary, and some dogs may attempt to escape even if they receive a shock. This leads to stress that is not warranted in the first place.

Safety Concerns 

Dogs could escape from yards enclosed by an invisible dog fence, as they may be willing to be shocked for this. As a result, this could lead to dogs being struck by cars or getting lost.

Whether invisible dog fences are humane depends on each individual owner’s situation. Invisible dog fences allow dogs with large, rural properties to exercise where they would not be able to inside a traditional fence. However, where there are chances of stray dogs or animals and children running around with little supervision, this may be too much pressure for owners and pets.

Nevertheless, if the choice has been made in favor of an invisible dog fence, the owner must dedicate time and effort to work effectively with their dogs during the training period. It is also necessary to ensure that the collar has enough battery charge and is fitted adequately to not get shocked too much. Still, keep in mind, owners should additionally use secure gates, supervise their pets outdoors, and teach pets to return when called to avoid potential problems.

Invisible dog fences may be better option than traditional methods of containing beloved pets in their yard, but it truly depends on the situation. Invisible fences are not a replacement for supervision or considered to be a foolproof enclosure for any dog who is determined to escape. Being aware of these limitations enables owners to use such systems effectively.